Labels

Showing posts with label Customs Compliance. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Customs Compliance. Show all posts

Saturday, June 22, 2013

ITAR Satellite Revisions... Thoughts


ISSUE

Obama, for all of his deficiencies or lack thereof (depending on your persuasion) in his political life as POTUS, has had the common sense to ensure that we get a revision of a part of the ITAR- or the International Traffic in Arms Regulations- that is in sore need of overhaul.  As part of his effort in the Export Controls Reform arena, Category XV of the US Munitions List ("USML"), is getting a serious tune-up.  I have written this post not only to explain to those of you who have absolutely no idea what I am talking about why these revisions are a godsend to those in the business of using satellites (Telecom, Media and Technology people will sympathize here) but also as a friendly reminder for any and all attorneys out there who have been sitting on their hands about sending in a revision suggestion- you have two weeks left to get it done (the call for input remains open until July 8th, 2013).

Nitty-Gritty

Last updated in 1999, as part of the Strom Thurmond National Defense Authorization Act, Category XV of ITAR (cited 22 C.F.R. § 121.1 XV) is focused on clearance for use of everything related to satellites.  While the call for revisions do seem to still hope to regulate satellites that can launch ICBM's, send death rays down to pinpointed locations on the earth a la  James Bond weaponry in Diamonds Are Forever and GoldenEye,  these general call seems to acknowledge that your standard satellite is more likely to be used for Google Maps, your cell phone call to your supplier in Rotterdam or to allow your Garmin to help you escape Jersey Turnpike Friday traffic rather than cutting edge technology that can can negate U.S. defensive capabilities.

Limitations still seem to include satellites that can:

  1. Assemble, refuel or otherwise aid in outer orbit transit
  2. Move faster than gravitational pull allows (If your satellite is volitionally moving faster than 9.8m/s^2, its probably more likely a missile or an object that can do harm. If its not volitional, well then we have a meteor and you have probably just suffered a multimillion dollar balance sheet hit on your PP&E)
  3. Has some capability (examples include kinetic, radio-frequency, laser charged particle device or "directed energy") to destroy or attack other satellites or something on the ground. I will be honest, when I read this part of the USML I think "Someone read too much Assimov as a kid" and "You know that there is probably some science we can't comprehend or left off that gets around technical restrictions of the USML but not the spirit"
  4. There are more, but those are the "fun" part of the list.

Remember- all these Satellites have to be pointed towards the earth. If you want to send a satellite to orbit Mars, it's not considered SME (Significant Military Equipment) and escapes all the ITAR hulabaloo (See note 3 to paragraph (a)(7)).


Take-Away Practitioners

- If you deal with ITAR and the DDTC on a regular basis regarding Category XV,  chances are you can now get your Technical Assistance Agreements, Manufacturing License Agreements, or Warehouse Distributions Agreements cleared out of the defense controls and into the relatively lower hassle realm of commercial export.

- July 8, 2013 is the deadline for revisions for Category XV of ITAR. If you think that there is something wrong with this part of the Munitions List, read through the call to change I linked to in the intro, and then make sure you get it in before the deadline (you have 16 days).

-If you don't deal with satellites (or the programs that run them or the component parts), then be thankful that haven't had to deal with something that was last updated when cell phones were as big as our faces (regrettably we may be heading back that way, but I digress).

-Lastly, this is about the 4th part of ITAR where there has been call to change this year (don't quote me on the number, but it seems to be a new category or chapter ever 2-3 months). So even if you are not dealing with Category XV but you are instead dealing with ITAR on a regular basis, please please please please check to see if there has been a new call for reform on your particular area. The DDTC isn't running through this in numerical order, so the part that affects your trade could be up next. Also side note- If the DDTC went through a revision in the past 2 or 3 years on a chapter that affects you, you can expect it to be a while before another overhaul.

Tuesday, June 18, 2013

Doha Talks Revisited Again.....

Interesting article on whether or not we truly need to get through another round of the DDA:

http://tax-news.com/features/TaxNews_Global_Trade__Do_We_Need_Doha__570572.html

ISSUE

Doha has honestly been deader than Bernie (of Weekend at Bernies fame). Too many differences of opinion, too little that has gotten done. It is the International trade equivalent of dating a movie star... I'm sure it would be really nice, and life would seem much easier, but the chances of it happening are slim to none and the unforeseen headaches that would accompany it would not be worth the trouble.

Nitty-Gritty

If you thought the Warsaw Pact or Roe v. Wade would be hot button issues... you have not read up on Doha. The Doha Development Agenda (DDA) is a current trade negotiation structured by the WTO to reduce global tariffs and trade barriers. Negotiations first started in November of 2001... yup it has been almost 12 years,  with the last break down of talks occurring in 2008 over agricultural import issues. To put the Doha Round in perspective:

1) It was started 2 months after 9/11, 18 months after the US accidental bombing of the Chinese Embassy in Kosovo, 3 years before the invention of Facebook. 
2) When talks broke down in 2008, the break down was so halting as to cause a separate round of talks about the meta of the talks themselves (talks about the procedures of the talks).
3) The break down in these talks "coincidentally"coincided with initiation of the the United States and 8 other countries in the Trans-Pacific Partnership FTA, Expansions of ASEAN, EU-South Korea FTA, etc.

To be fair, the DDA seemed like it faced an uphill battle. At the time talks had broken down, the Lisbon Treaty (forming the EU) had been signed but not sealed incurring transition period issues, among them the best direction for the EU in trade strategy. China's leadership was turning a blind eye to blatant IP infringement of EU and US technologies, the US was facing a huge change in leadership and The Great Recession.... the bottom line: all the big players had internal factors that made exploring a unified external position with regards to trade barriers a long shot.


Take-Away

President Obama's announcement of renewed trade negotiations between the US and EU at the G8 has caused speculation that Doha might yet actually be completed (for my analysis of the announcement, see this post). I am not very hopeful that Doha will ever be completed, and it seems like the big players in the world have just gone ahead and negotiated smaller agreements with each other, undercutting the urgency which would rekindle the Doha fire. reduced global tariffs, lightened embargoes and a World Unified customs classification system could increase the money in a exporters pocket ten-fold, but some of this is politics, some of this is protectionism, and not as much of it is common sense.
In the meantime, for those of you in the US reading this who would like a better perspective on recent EU FTA developments and the possibility of the G8 talks amounting to meaningful, translatable change for the common custom's brokerage, check this article out: EU perspective on FTA with the US.

Saturday, June 15, 2013

Customs Compliance- Equal Protection against the HTSUS?

Larry has a great blog on U.S. Customs Law (I urge you all to read it religiously if you are more legally oriented in the industry and significantly interacting with U.S. Customs), and his most recent post sums up the demise of a good attempt to work around the HTSUS classification tables by bringing claims of constitutionally violative discrimination.

Issue:

Customs Law: Equal Protection Claims Dismissed

Nitty-Gritty

After reading the opinion (also linked in Larry's post), I have to say that this appears, probably to everyone else also prepping for the bar, that the legal theory under which the case was brought is a stretch... mostly because the HTSUS sounds exactly like the basic hypo they give in Barbri or Kaplan PMBR to show acts (laws, regulations, etc.) serving a public good or welfare purpose that are not overtly discriminatory which nevertheless effect a certain group more than another group usually win the Equal Protections' arguments.

Take-Away

The HTSUS is what it is (all 3546 pages of it), and frankly I would fathom companies have a better chance arguing EP discrimination of the law or executive agreement made to allow the classification for that part of the HTSUS rather than the HTSUS itself (i.e. you have a better shot at proving NAFTA discriminates than the HTSUS, and even the NAFTA argument is probably not a good one either). I would also think arguing that your particular product fits under a more favourable classification should be the first attempt, rather than venture into the ethereal realm of "constitutional law settling business transactions", but they may have already tried that.